I wanted to share this... victory? Achievement? I don't know quite what to call it, but I did it, damn it! I finally sold the Spider-Man 2 Limited Edition PS5 console that I bought on day one of its release!
Why I Bought Another PS5
I already owned two PlayStation 5 consoles, but when Sony announced a Limited Edition version for Spider-Man 2, I had to get it!
Limited Editions don't come around often. There are bundles and things like that, but it's SPIDER-MAN!
PS5s weren't exactly hard to come by anymore, and it seemed like everyone who wanted one already had one by then, so I didn't expect demand to be particularly high. Still, I pre-ordered one because I figured my local GameStop wouldn't get many extras. Honestly, I think I was probably the only person who pre-ordered one from that location.
Sony not only announced the Limited Edition console, but also a matching DualSense controller, console covers, and Spider-Man 2 bundles.
Now, if you already own a PS5, why not just buy the face covers and controller?
Well, because there's also the appeal of getting a newer hardware revision. Sometimes manufacturers make slight changes to internal components like the fan, motherboard, cooling system, power supply, etc. Not necessarily performance upgrades, but refinements nonetheless.
And besides, it's SPIDER-MAN!
Three Years in the Closet
So, let's get to the meat and potatoes.
Potatoes!
Get it? From... the movie... Brand New Day.
No?
You better go watch it then! Such a great film. Punisher. Hulk. Jean Grey.
Anyway, I already had my PS5 with games installed and additional storage, so I didn't want to open another console and have to redownload everything. That would've taken forever!
I figured I'd at least open it to use the code for the game, right?
Wrong.
I loved the first Spider-Man game and completed 100% of it. And can you believe that, to this very day, October 2026, I STILL have not played Spider-Man 2?!
Okay, enough already.
So, the console sat in my office closet for three years. Completely unopened, with the original factory seal on the slipcover still intact. Even the pre-order pickup sticker GameStop placed on the box was still there!
And that's where it stayed, despite all my brother's attempts to take it home with him.
"You're not using it!" he would always tell me.
"You've already got a PS5. TWO of them!"
Yeah, but this is a Spider-Man 2 LIMITED EDITION!
Eventually, I decided that although I didn't need to sell it for money or anything like that, I could probably make a profit from it because of its rarity.
So, onto Facebook Marketplace it went.
33 Weeks on Facebook Marketplace
TL;DR, after 33 weeks on Facebook Marketplace, I had TWO serious offers. The rest were mostly trades and lowballers.
The first was from someone in PA who offered to pay for shipping because they apparently get it free through work or something. But then they asked if my price was firm and mentioned they were working with a budget.
You can probably guess where that conversation went.
Their offer was... hang on, let me pull up Messenger...
"My price point being $500 - $570."
Yeah, no.
This console cost me over $700 after taxes!
Oh, and correction. They were actually from NY, originally from PA. I could've gone back and edited that, but I didn't feel like it. Besides, I'm trying to maximize my character usage here.
The next serious offer came just last week.
The message opened with, "Hi can i take for 900$?"
Now, Messenger warned me that this person might not be in the country, so naturally, I was a little suspicious. I didn't want to be rude and immediately accuse someone of being a scammer, so I asked where they were located.
San Antonio.
Okay, not too far.
They asked if I was happy with the offer, and of course I said yes!
Then they asked if I could ship it to San Antonio... and yes, I know what you're all thinking, but wait...
They also asked if picking it up would be better.
I explained that shipping and insurance would only add to the cost, so picking it up made more sense.
And surprisingly, everything was going smoothly. Almost TOO smoothly compared to my usual Marketplace experiences.
Then they asked if I needed a deposit.
A deposit?!
That's a lot of trust to put into a stranger on Facebook Marketplace. I mean, what's stopping someone from taking your deposit and disappearing?
I declined, but asked if they were planning to pick it up that day. They wanted to come the following week instead, which was fine with me, so I marked the listing as pending.
At that point, I was still keeping an eye out for a possible scam, but things were looking pretty good.
Wait... You're From WHERE?!
Originally, we arranged for a morning pickup because they'd never driven to my area before.
Then, earlier in the week, they asked if we could move the pickup back a day, which I didn't mind. But shortly afterward, I got another message saying they'd be in Austin the day before and could pick it up that night instead.
Even better!
Night came around, they showed up, and I met them outside.
Everything went smoothly. No last-minute price negotiations, no excuses, and no strange payment requests.
During our conversation, I found out that the console was actually a gift for a friend.
Apparently, they'd been looking everywhere for this particular edition and couldn't find one in stock.
And honestly, I knew exactly what they were talking about.
I'd already looked around myself, and the listings I found on eBay, Mercari, and other third-party marketplaces were asking upwards of $1,200!
BEFORE SHIPPING!
But then they told me they'd seen listings going for...
Get this...
NEARLY $2,000!
For the Spider-Man 2 Limited Edition PS5!
Now, I don't know if anyone was actually paying those prices, but that's what some sellers were asking.
Then, while we were talking about San Antonio, I found out something I absolutely wasn't expecting.
They weren't actually from Texas.
They weren't even from the United States!
They were from...
AUSTRALIA!
AUSTRALIA?!
They had flown in from Australia and were staying with a friend!
And here they were, buying my Spider-Man 2 PS5 from Facebook Marketplace!
I mean, what are the odds?!
And considering the exchange rate between U.S. and Australian dollars, those already ridiculous prices were even more expensive from their perspective.
Suddenly, my $900 asking price probably looked pretty good compared to what they'd been finding elsewhere!
But what really got me was that this wasn't even for them. It was a gift for a friend!
I don't know who this friend is, but brother, SHE'S A KEEPER!
You better get her something just as expensive if she's willing to go through all this trouble to get you a gift... from a stranger off Facebook Marketplace!
I even got her a bag for it, per her request. It was the least I could do considering she'd made the drive from the San Antonio area.
After 33 weeks of dealing with Marketplace nonsense, the console was finally SOLD!
Was It Worth It?
I'm sad to see it go, but happy to have found it a home.
It's probably the first time I've ever gotten rid of a console that I originally intended to keep as part of my collection.
For those wondering how much I made, I came out a little over $200 ahead.
Not bad for something that had been sitting unopened in my closet for three years!
I originally listed it for around $980, I think, or maybe a little higher, before eventually reducing the price to $960. The final sale was $900.
And you should've seen all the bullshit offers flooding my inbox during those 33 weeks.
It doesn't matter what you have something listed for. Even if you say FIRM, you're still going to get trade offers and lowball offers that'll make you laugh and want to block someone.
But hey, it finally sold, and to someone who seemed genuinely happy to have found it.
Hopefully, the friend receiving it will be just as thrilled!
Now, if I could only find a Star Wars Battlefront II Edition PS4 Pro, I'd be REALLY happy.
I already have the Battlefront I edition, but I NEED the BFII edition too!

